Flock Ecogames

My Blog for STEM Games and System Models

Recent Posts

  • Complimentary colors
  • The Art & Science of Spirals
  • Math, science & awe
  • Tolerance & segregation
  • How the tiger got its stripes
  • Balancing, tipping & survival

Recent Comments

  • K.J. Keane on How the tiger got its stripes
  • K.J. Keane on How the tiger got its stripes
  • K.J. Keane on Math, science & awe
  • K.J. Keane on Math, science & awe
  • Complimentary colors in spirals on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • flock on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • K.J. Keane on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • K.J. Keane on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • Natasha on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • Study of emerging patterns links science, technology, engineering, math and art, and stimulates awe. on The Art & Science of Spirals
  • dogEt on Math, science & awe
  • Natasha on How the tiger got its stripes
  • Natasha on Tolerance & segregation
  • Natasha on Math, science & awe

social links

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube

Archives

  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • Landing Page
  • Blog Page
  • Archive Page

Powered by Genesis

Math, science & awe

April 21, 2017 by flock 4 Comments

Many scientists have confessed to experiencing awe when beholding nature’s vast complexity of forms. But only recently have researchers systematically studied causes and consequence of experiencing awe. One cause of awe is vastness of scope, size or complexity, experiments revealed. The same experiments found that one consequence of awe is altruism (Piff et al 2015). Beholding a forest of cypress trees evoked a feeling of awe which, in turn, stimulated altruistic behavior. The researchers (Piff et al 2015) credit the awe to witnessing vastness. They also found that small things that were vast in complexity had the same effect as the cypress forest. A drop of colored dye spreading in milk also triggered the altruism after evoking a feeling of awe. It is a vastness of complexity, not sheer size, since the swirling droplet provoked awe-altruism, and awe-altruism didn’t result when persons looked up at a tall and relatively plain building. Neither can we just credit positive feelings, since witnessing tornadoes evoked fear and, at the same time, had the awe-to-altruism effect.

Emerging patterns may stimulate awe.

What do these awe-striking images have in common? The droplet of colored dye splashes outwards in milk, breaking into smaller droplets projecting in all directions, but ultimately merging back into the milk in a new homogeneity. In all these experiences evoking awe-altruism, it seems to me, patterns emerge. In cases such as the cypress forest, the patterns may emerge because our perspective is changing. When I’m in a forest, my eyes travel upwards and back, looking at trees close, then up to far away treetops. On the way up, I see branching out into ever more diversity. Patterns emerge. The tops of the trees, due to their distance from us, converge towards a vanishing point.

Another feature of many of these images is that the patterns repeat in the smaller and smaller parts. For example, we see the same level of branching off, at smaller and smaller levels (or larger and larger) sizes. Many growth processes in nature, like branching out of growing trees or developing lungs, result in patterns repeating across scales, where the shape of the whole is reflected in the smaller and smaller parts. These patterns are called fractals. The spirals of cyclones are fractal, similar across scales, and can aggregate into tornadoes. Very often a simple natural process aggregates into patterns that repeat at different sizes. An irregularity at one size, repeats at larger and larger scales, such that there is a symmetry across scales, as in a snowflake, or in spirals.

In these patterns that nature produces, the whole has symmetry, an order not seen in isolated parts. The number of scales the pattern repeats can be very large, and that is a source of complexity, while the fact that the patterns are the same are a type of order, a self-similarity across scales. Thus, fractals have a certain level of complexity, while the repeating of the same pattern across scales, the symmetry, makes the complexity more intelligible, pleasing and, as recent research revealed, relaxing (Hägerhäll et al 2015). Many of these natural patterns that stimulate awe and altruism are fractals, associated with a certain degree of complexity. Hägerhäll and colleagues (2015) found that fractals in nature stimulated brainwaves associated with positive affect and relaxation. They believe that our brains and visual perceptual system are hard-wired to understand the level of complexity associated with such fractals. Images with complexity greater than a fractal in nature, such as seen in a forest, overwhelm our minds. They conclude that humans need to see this type of fractal by getting out into nature, spending time in forests where we are surrounded by fractals. Fascinatingly, they found the same fractal patterns in Jackson Pollock paintings. They created their own abstract art that also would match the fractal patterns of forests. This art had the same soothing effect on human nervous systems, their experiments revealed. Now, I’m particularly interested in this topic, partly because I found fractal patterns with this level of complexity in my simulations of human interactions (Keane 2016, Journal of Theoretical Biology). More fundamentally, I feel a great sense of awe, as well as relaxation, meditating on fractals in nature and art.  I suspect that patterns emerging at many scales may be the source of awe of the experiences in the experiments (by Piff and colleagues 2015). Placing ourselves in the context of these larger scales of size and complexity may be what evokes the altruism, the selfless giving.

These patterns are also surprising. Patterns emerge in the whole that you would not expect based on the simple rules of interaction of the parts. You can see this in our two board games, Tip and Tolerance. Tolerance shows how segregation emerges even when no one wants it. Blue and red crabs start out completely integrated: Blue crabs are next to more red crabs than blue, and red crabs are next to more blue crabs than red. Players take turns moving crabs, just trying to find a few similar neighbors for most of their crabs. There are no extra points for finding mostly same neighbors, since crabs are very tolerant of difference. Yet massive segregation usually results. Thus the board game Tolerance shows a pattern emerging that you would not expect based on the simple game rules (video). We show an alternative game that destroys segregation. In this way the game introduces a practical application of pattern emergence and offers some insight into an important social issue. Our game Tip also shows patterns of segregation emerging, but also shows coexistence often results from gameplay, even when the players are trying to eliminate each other. You try to take over the ecosystem, but coexistence is hard to overcome. Again a surprising pattern emerges. I give a quick glimpse of how this happens in Tip and Tolerance in this video. You can explore this in more depth with our computer models of both games, and many more system models, all of which you can run through a web browser.

One more thing about these emerging patterns that inspires me. Math is about patterns of relationships. Science explains what gives rise to the patterns. With computers, we can create system models that generate this patterning, very often with very simple code, and use the models to solve problems. We do this with spirals, and use the images in our coloring book. The beautiful patterns that emerge inspire art. There’s a movement called the art of emergence, art in the age of emergence, or generative art. Studying the emergence of these patterns, as we do in Tip and Tolerance, can engage Science, Technology, Engineering, Math (STEM) and Art (STEAM).

More to read:

Bies AJ, Blanc-Goldhammer DR, Boydston CR, Taylor RP, Sereno ME. 2016. Aesthetic Responses to Exact Fractals Driven by Physical Complexity. Front. Hum. Neurosci.;10:210. doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2016.00210

Hagerhall CM, Laike T, Küller M, Marcheschi E, Boydston C, Taylor RP. 2015.Human physiological benefits of viewing nature: EEG responses to exact and statistical fractal patterns. Nonlinear Dynamics Psychol Life Sci. 19(1):1-12.

Keane C. 2016a. Chaos in Collective Health: Fractal Dynamics of Social Learning. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 409: 47-59.

Piff PK, Dietze P, Feinberg M, Stancato DM, Keltner D. 2015. Awe, the Small Self, and Prosocial Behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 108(6): 883-899.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Category #1 Tagged With: awe, fractals, S.T.E.M., Threaded Comments

Comments

  1. Natasha says

    April 27, 2017 at 7:04 pm

    I’m the type of person who cringes at the word “math”. I’ve never been good at it so I’ve never really enjoyed it. Plus, this “new math” teachers are using now days seems to complicate it even more. *Sigh*

    However, reading this post really expanded my mind and encouraged me to look at it from a different perspective. It inspires me to focus more on emerging patterns by using the world around me. For lack of better words, it simplified things for me.

    Not only that, but I love how the author shared that fractals in nature stimulate our brain waves associated with positive affect and relaxation. How awesome is that? I often forget that there are so many complicated and intricate small parts that work to make up a whole. I think sometimes we take that for granted as humans… especially in nature when we enjoy the sight of snowflakes or even the view of an ocean.

    Great post!

    Reply
  2. dogEt says

    April 28, 2017 at 12:51 am

    Magnificent web site. Lots of useful info here. I am sending it to several friends ans also sharing in delicious. And certainly, thanks for your effort!
    dogEt

    Reply
  3. K.J. Keane says

    June 9, 2017 at 9:15 pm

    For me experiencing architecture is awe inspiring. Within these complex buildings structural forms and decorative motifs are combined to transform the mundane world into an otherworldly place halfway between heaven and earth. In Gloucester Cathedral (1351-64), the complex system of structural support for the vaulted ceiling is a series of “fan” vaults. While serving their structural purpose, they tower over the cloister and reach across overhead like the branches of trees lining a path through a forest. The combination of structural forms and surface decoration evoke a fantasy forest where the branches are balanced and evenly spaced. You are walking through not just any forest, but a perfect forest… a heavenly forest. The impressive order of the elements, all calculated with mathematical precision, combine to create an environment that affect the visitor in a visceral way. The huge scale of these monuments dwarfs the individual and reminds us of brevity of human life, the grandeur of the Divine, and the inherent beauty of Nature, which in the rhythm of its rugged forms is found the fingerprint of the Creator.

    http://www.catchingthemagic.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/IMG_7966.jpg

    Reply
    • K.J. Keane says

      June 9, 2017 at 9:29 pm

      Another view of Gloucester Cathedral cloister
      http://indulgy.com/post/Xgsb4NQ8U2/gloucester-cathedral-england

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *